Pantonic Live! - The CD! - A Critical Review

by -- Frankie McIntosh

From the “Pantonic Live” CD
Provided with the expressed permission of Basement Recordings

Clive Bradley on stage with Pantonic for “In My House” - 1999

Rather abruptly, our Sociology professor asked for an example of a “synergistic collaboration”; silence pervaded the room; that was during my college freshman year.  Today, without hesitation, I’d holler “the Pantonic Live CD!”. This musical masterpiece is a product of the joint efforts of:  veteran arranger Clive Bradley; the Pantonic Steel Orchestra led by Keith Roberts; and Basement Recordings’ sound crew, directed by distinguished engineer, musician, and educator Trevor John.

My discussion of the work reveals a professional bias, in that I (an arranger), dwell largely upon the musical imagination of Clive Bradley, with particular focus on Andre Tanker’s Ben Lion (extended version, track #3).

Despite multiple levels of internal activity, Ben Lion maintains remarkable outward stability and coherence.   Bradley’s craftsmanship on this piece supports a conviction I have long held: the term “arranger” as applied to many in the pan world, is a misnomer.   These artists are bona fide composers, their inventiveness far transcending the bounds of arranging.  (See further discussion of Ben Lion under “Addendum” below.)

Clive Bradley on stage with Pantonic for “Stranger” - 2001

Shadow’s Stranger is imbued with a strong rhythmic drive, the warmth of Caribbean sunshine and the smell of ripe mango. Kudos to the engine room here. The listener’s initial response may be involuntary toe tapping, but his mind is also addressed.

I found myself returning to the dramatic opening, where full orchestra seems to spell out “Stra…..n-ger”.  Sixteen measures later it’s time for a change in texture; consequently, frontline pans descend over a bass pedal, while the middle section sustains a supporting harmony.  Eight measures ensue, and there’s now a need for more spirited activity (excitement!): A rapid, rising, chromatic run, played in unison, deliberately excludes basses.  Why?  So that the rapid, descending, diatonic run which follows, will include basses --- thereby providing contrast --- not only in melodic direction, but in weight as well.  Another key feature is the ‘breakdown’ in the middle of the piece, introducing dynamic and timbral change, as well as the element of surprise.

Clive Bradley on stage with Pantonic for Ben Lion - 2002

Recording a one-hundred plus piece steel orchestra outdoors, live, poses a challenge which only the most proficient sound engineers are prepared to meet.   The New York art community widely acknowledges Trevor John to be among those of his profession who reside on Mount Olympus.  The orchestral balance which he and the crew capture on the Pantonic Live CD (most notably Oba’s ‘Picture on my Wall; and In my House), validates this reputation.

Bradley’s ‘big-band’ voicings and linear interaction required (especially so on cuts #5 and #6): correct mike placement and recording levels for each section of the orchestra; EQ which would enhance the natural sound of the instruments without distortion; and sensitive, experienced ears.  Trevor’s musical background was certainly an asset in this regard.   Main and secondary lines --- supporting harmonies --driving percussion --- all are heard in proper perspective.

Clive Bradley on stage with Pantonic for Picture On My Wall - 2000

Through insightful interpretation, Pantonic’s performers bring the music to life with spirit and elegance.  Their crescendos leading from chorus to verse (and elsewhere), in “In my House”, evince superb dynamic control.  The precision and clarity with which complex chromatic sequences are executed; proficiency in changing tone color; alternating between back and front of the stick; ease in moving from lyrical legato to detached staccato (the melody of ‘Picture on my Wall’ for example)-- these skills bespeak countless hours of individual and group practice.   They represent a significant element in the formula, which renders Pantonic Live a rare treasure.

In today’s world of commercial radio, intelligible musical substance; creativity; and engineering excellence seem (in many cases), to have become disqualifying factors for airplay.  I applaud the producers of Pantonic Live in my prediction that radio exposure will be limited to such aware and discerning forums as Basement Recordings website and the Trevor Wilkins show.

Pantonic Steel Orchestra - Ben Lion - 2002

I’ve tried to keep technical terms at a minimum, but it seemed impossible to dispense with them altogether, and yet convey to the reader some sense of the underlying formal features with which Clive Bradley invested his work; those same features that make us dance, shout, or listen attentively.

A further look at Ben Lion (for musicians and sane humans alike):

Arising, five-note motive taken from Tanker’s opening, introduces Ben Lion.  First appearing in B minor, it establishes the mood of the piece.  (In due course, this unit is imitated, transposed, offset contrapuntally, tossed among various sections of the orchestra, and subtly disguised --- never disappearing, however, since even when not sounding, its presence is felt).

The first motive is joined by a second --- more lyrical in character --- also from Tanker’s opening.

Our main theme (Andre Tanker’s chorus, verse, and refrain melody) is then firmly established in B minor by means of repetition.

A modulatory transition based on motives from the introduction is the next salient event. The second (lyrical) introductory motive is transformed here into an expressive eight-bar melody in D minor, which contrasts so well with the main theme, that there is a temptation to hear it as a secondary theme, which would be developed later. (Clive has different plans.)

The 4 pans and cellos, amid contrapuntal interplay with tenors, restate verse, chorus and refrain of the primary theme in D minor. (At the risk of imposing Sonata Allegro form on Ben Lion, I’d venture to call the foregoing an Exposition).

A second transition, exploiting a verse figure, moves through the cycle of fifths to D major. Here we come face to face with composer Bradley, who seems to be saying “Make no mistake about it, you’re in the ‘Development’ section at this point.”

Pantonic Steel Orchestra - Stranger - 2001

All stops are now out.  Tanker’s melody is fragmented, transformed, and placed in curious harmonic and modal settings.   Freshly created material drawing upon Blues, Salsa and Jazz idioms, reveals the artist’s (Bradley) broad musical experience and vocabulary.  So absorbing is the unfolding, we find ourselves in G minor without being sure how we got there!

At this juncture one wonders how Bradley will return to the opening key of B minor after having ventured so far a field.  Well he doesn’t, and we come to realize that it was never his intention to do so.  The two introductory motives are restated (in G minor instead of B minor); a ‘G’ minor roll ends the piece; and we are left with images of Clive Bradley smiling, “Gotcha!”

click to watch video performance



Franklyn “Maestro” McIntosh aka Frankie McIntosh has helped to elevate calypso to great prominence, arranging and composing music for artists like the Calypso King of the World Mighty Sparrow, Beckett, Scorcher, Chalkdust, Shadow, Explainer and a host of other outstanding musicians.

click to order CD

Listen To The Master on Pantonic Live! CD Audio Samples

More info on Pantonic Live CD

 More on Clive Bradley

Leave a comment in the WST Forum